not okay, Amanda Palmer, not okay

[hermionesviolin]

I've never had any real involvement with Amanda Palmer, but I have friends who were fans. I first heard about the Evelyn Evelyn project I have no idea where, but I heard about it in a way that made me think it was Amanda Palmer and Jason Webley pretending to be conjoined twins. How this was "edgy" or "artsy" or whatever was totally lost on me, but I didn't really engage with it. Then the Evelyn Evelyn thing blew up on the Internet a couple of weeks ago. I read AFP's big blogpost telling the Evelyn Evelyn backstory [before it got edited], and reading it I took it totally at face value -- apparently missed whatever cues were supposed to tell me it was performance art. (I've read that the promo vid and such are pretty transparent, and I don't doubt that.) I read a whole bunch of critiques of the project [e.g., this and this, if you're unfamiliar and want a place to start] and of Amanda's (and Jason's) responses to the critiques. I agree with the people who think the Evelyn Evelyn project is problematic and that Amanda and Jason should have been more thoughtful. I'm skeptical of Amanda and Jason's "oh, if you'd learned EE's tragic backstory through the beautiful art that is the album, instead of this blogpost, you wouldn't be so offended," and am not really interested in withholding judgment until the album comes out. I've not been entirely unsympathetic to Amanda and Jason, though.

Then sharpest_rose linked to this. I am officially repulsed by Amanda Palmer.

Edit: sharpest_rose posted:

I have put all my Dresden Dolls and Amanda Palmer stuff up for auction.

I will be donating the high bid to a charity which supports disabled women; I'm happy to work out the specifics of which organisation and what name the donation is given under with the winner of the auction.

Please pass on the link and spread the word. Let's make something beautiful grow out of this dirt.

Comments

[reflectedeve.livejournal.com]

Repulsive is the right word.

Gah. Sorry. Very, very upset, naturally.

[hermionesviolin.livejournal.com]

Don't worry about me, sweetie. *I* say JFC and the like (though I'm trying to train myself out of it), and I always think it's terribly sweet when people catch themselves around me.

*hugs you*

[undeny.livejournal.com]

I used to be such a fan. I really admired Amanda Palmer in the past, but this has just been too much.

[hedy.livejournal.com]

Same here. It bugs me tht she's marketed herself as being this alterna-"feminist" vibe, but is unafraid to what brings in the money.